7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Previously Withheld Batson Explanations May Be Considered on a Remand Authorizing All Three Steps

Date: Oct 15, 2026

Previously Withheld Batson Explanations May Be Considered on a Remand Authorizing All Three Steps Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit Decision date: October 14, 2026...

Anders Review: Established Search, Joinder, and Sentencing Rules Foreclose a Nonfrivolous Drug-Conviction Appeal

Date: Oct 15, 2026

Anders Review: Established Search, Joinder, and Sentencing Rules Foreclose a Nonfrivolous Drug-Conviction Appeal Case: United States v. Eugene Alexander Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Rule 41(g) Permits Wiping a Seized Cellphone Before Return When Selective Deletion Cannot Adequately Protect a Minor

Date: Oct 15, 2026

Rule 41(g) Permits Wiping a Seized Cellphone Before Return When Selective Deletion Cannot Adequately Protect a Minor Case: United States v. Steven Stathas, Jr. Court: United States Court of Appeals...

Rule 41(g): Returning a Seized Cellphone May Be Conditioned on Wiping Harmful Data

Date: Oct 15, 2026

Rule 41(g): Returning a Seized Cellphone May Be Conditioned on Wiping Harmful Data Case: United States v. Steven Stathas, Jr. Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit Decided:...

Section 7434 Does Not Provide a Damages Remedy for Fraudulent Form 1099-C Filings

Date: Oct 6, 2026

Section 7434 Does Not Provide a Damages Remedy for Fraudulent Form 1099-C Filings Case: John Jacoby v. Idlewild Country Club Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit Date:...

Hospital Safety Evidence Can Establish Title VII Undue Hardship for Denying a Religious Vaccine Exemption

Date: Oct 5, 2026

Hospital Safety Evidence Can Establish Title VII Undue Hardship for Denying a Religious Vaccine Exemption Case: Brooke Mason v. Cook County, Illinois Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

United States v. Gary Howard: Self-Incrimination Prevails Over Compulsory Process, and Inevitable Discovery Extends to Cell-Phone Evidence

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Self-Incrimination Prevails Over Compulsory Process, and Inevitable Discovery Extends to Cell-Phone Evidence Case: United States v. Gary Howard Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh...

Pending State-Court Docket Orders: Younger Abstention and Immunity for Judicial Acts

Date: Sep 24, 2026

Pending State-Court Docket Orders: Younger Abstention and Immunity for Judicial Acts Mary Joanna Comer v. Daniel Joseph Tolan (Seventh Circuit, September 22, 2026) is a nonprecedential disposition....

Unauthorized Taking Can Support a Stolen-Firearm Enhancement in a Felon-in-Possession Case

Date: Sep 24, 2026

Unauthorized Taking Can Support a Stolen-Firearm Enhancement in a Felon-in-Possession Case Introduction In United States v. Charles Perdue, II, the Seventh Circuit considered whether any nonfrivolous...

Indiana Good-Time Credit Cannot Be Transferred from a Completed Sentence to a Consecutive Sentence

Date: Sep 24, 2026

Indiana Good-Time Credit Cannot Be Transferred from a Completed Sentence to a Consecutive Sentence Case: Aaron Isby v. Delana Gardner Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit...

Occasional On-Call Availability Can Be an Essential Job Function Under the Rehabilitation Act

Date: Sep 24, 2026

Occasional On-Call Availability Can Be an Essential Job Function Under the Rehabilitation Act Case: Alexia Knox v. Wisconsin Department of Transportation Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Concurrent Dog Sniffs Do Not Unlawfully Prolong Diligently Pursued Traffic Stops, and Valid Appeal Waivers Bar Sentencing Review

Date: Sep 24, 2026

Concurrent Dog Sniffs Do Not Unlawfully Prolong Diligently Pursued Traffic Stops, and Valid Appeal Waivers Bar Sentencing Review Case: United States v. Lamone Lauderdale Court: United States Court of...

Seventh Circuit Tightens § 10(j): No Presumed Irreparable Harm; Specific, Employee-Rights-Focused Proof Required (and Delay Undercuts Relief)

Date: Sep 20, 2026

Seventh Circuit Tightens § 10(j): No Presumed Irreparable Harm; Specific, Employee-Rights-Focused Proof Required (and Delay Undercuts Relief) Case: Angie Cowan Hamada v. Laborforce, LLC, No. 25-3110...

Buggs v. McNulty: No Fourth Amendment Claim When a Visitor Remains on School Property After Being Told to Leave

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Buggs v. McNulty: No Fourth Amendment Claim When a Visitor Remains on School Property After Being Told to Leave Introduction In Robert Buggs v. Paige McNulty and Gary Community School Corporation...

MPPAA Rule: Prior Partial-Withdrawal Credit Applies After Full § 1381(b) Calculation (Including the § 1399 20-Year Cap)

Date: Sep 19, 2026

MPPAA Rule: Prior Partial-Withdrawal Credit Applies After Full § 1381(b) Calculation (Including the § 1399 20-Year Cap) I. Introduction In Central States, Southeast and Southwest Areas Pension Fund...

Partial-Withdrawal Credit Applies After Full § 1381 Calculation, Including the 20-Year Cap

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Partial-Withdrawal Credit Applies After Full § 1381 Calculation, Including the 20-Year Cap Case: Consumers Concrete Corp. v. Central States, Southeast and Southwest Areas Pension Fund Court: Seventh...

Mootness Remand Under FRAP 12.1(b): Vacatur of a Preliminary Injunction to Eliminate Appellate Jurisdiction

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Mootness Remand Under FRAP 12.1(b): Vacatur of a Preliminary Injunction to Eliminate Appellate Jurisdiction Introduction American Academy of Pediatrics v. James Uthmeier (7th Cir. Sept. 14, 2026) is...

Strict Local Rule 56.1 Compliance and Comparator Proof Requirements in Title VII Summary Judgment (Seventh Circuit)

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Strict Local Rule 56.1 Compliance and Comparator Proof Requirements in Title VII Summary Judgment (Seventh Circuit) 1. Introduction In Yousef A. Ismail v. David Steiner, Postmaster General, the...

Post-Removal Mootness of § 2241 Detention Challenges and Issue Preservation Limits on Third-Country Removal Claims

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Post-Removal Mootness of § 2241 Detention Challenges and Issue Preservation Limits on Third-Country Removal Claims 1. Introduction Case: Mario Javier Cedeno-Gonzalez v. Markwayne Mullin, et al....

No ADA/Section 504 Requirement for an IDEA-Style Manifestation Determination Before Denying Transfer Reenrollment; Title IX Claim Waived When Omitted from Statement of Claims

Date: Sep 12, 2026

No ADA/Section 504 Requirement for an IDEA-Style Manifestation Determination Before Denying Transfer Reenrollment; Title IX Claim Waived When Omitted from Statement of Claims I. Introduction E.W. v....